Lets have more green trees

I have been working on making jobs ignore intermittent failures for mochitests (bug 1036325) on try servers to prevent unnecessary oranges, and save resources that goes into retriggering those jobs on tbpl. I am glad to announce that this has been achieved for desktop mochitests (linux, osx and windows). It doesn’t work for android/b2g mochitests but they will be supported in the future. This post explains how it works in detail and is a bit lengthy, so bear with me.

Lets see the patch in action. Here is an example of an almost green try push:

Tbpl Push Log

 Note: one bc1 orange job is because of a leak (Bug 1036328)

In this push, the intermittents were suppressed, for example this log shows an intermittent on mochitest-4 job on linux :


Even though there was an intermittent failure for this job, the job remains green. We can determine if a job produced an intermittent  by inspecting the number of tests run for the job on tbpl, which will be much smaller than normal. For example in the above intermittent mochitest-4 job it shows “mochitest-plain-chunked: 4696/0/23” as compared to the normal “mochitest-plain-chunked: 16465/0/1954”. Another way is looking at the log of the particular job for “TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL”.


The algorithm behind getting a green job even in the presence of an intermittent failure is that we recognize the failing test, and run it independently 10 times. If the test fails < 3 times out of 10, it is marked as intermittent and we leave it. If it fails >=3 times out of 10, it means that there is a problem in the test turning the job orange.


Next to test the case of a “real” failure, I wrote a unit test and tested it out in the try push:


This job is orange and the log for this push is:


In this summary, a test is failing for more than three times and hence we get a real failure. The important line in this summary is:

3086 INFO TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL | Bisection | Please ignore repeats and look for ‘Bleedthrough’ (if any) at the end of the failure list

This tells us that the bisection procedure has started and we should look out for future “Bleedthrough”, that is, the test causing the failure. And at the last line it prints the “real failure”:

TEST-UNEXPECTED-FAIL | testing/mochitest/tests/Harness_sanity/test_harness_post_bisection.html | Bleedthrough detected, this test is the root cause for many of the above failures

Aha! So we have found a permanent failing test and it is probably due to some fault in the developer’s patch. Thus, the developers can now focus on the real problem rather than being lost in the intermittent failures.

This patch has landed on mozilla-inbound and I am working on enabling it as an option on trychooser (More on that in the next blog post). However if someone wants to try this out now (works only for desktop mochitest), one can hack in just a single line:

options.bisectChunk = ‘default’

such as in this diff inside runtests.py and test it out!

Hopefully, this will also take us a step closer to AutoLand (automatic landing of patches).

Other Bugs Solved for GSoC:

[1028226] – Clean up the code for manifest parsing
[1036374] – Adding a binary search algorithm for bisection of failing tests
[1035811] – Mochitest manifest warnings dumped at start of each robocop test

A big shout out to my mentor (Joel Maher) and other a-team members for helping me in this endeavour!

GSoC 2014: Progress Report

In the last month, a good deal of work has been done on the Mochitest Failure Investigator project. I have described the algorithms implemented for bisecting the tests in my previous post. Since then, I have worked on including “sanity-check” once the cause of failure is found in which the tests are re-run omitting the cause of failure. The advantage of doing this is that if suppose a test is failing due to >1 number of previous tests, then we can find all those tests which are causing the failure. I then worked on refactoring the patch to integrate it seamlessly with the existing code. Andrew and Joel gave me good suggestions to make the code more beautiful and readable, and it has been a challenging and a great learning experience . The patch is now in the final review stages and it is successfully passing for all platforms on tbpl: https://tbpl.mozilla.org/?tree=Try&rev=07bbcb4a3e98. Apart from this, I worked on a small fun bug (925699) which was not cleaning up the unwanted temporary files, eventually occupying a large space on my machine.

Now since the proposed project is almost over and I still have a month and a half left, after discussing with my mentor, I am planning to cover up a few extra things:

* support finding the cause of failure in case of a timeout/crash for a chunk

* support for intermittent problems – this case is interesting, as we may be able to support AutoLand by using this.

* validating new tests to reduce intermittent problems caused by their addition.

Until next time!